Greece: School flag-bearers will be chosen by lot, rather than achievement reports:

The government has scrapped a long tradition of honoring top pupils by selecting them to carry the national flag in school parades. From now on flag-bearers will be chosen by lot. Opposition parties criticized this as part of the SYRIZA party’s assault on excellence.

A presidential decree published in the Government Gazette on Tuesday sets out the new procedure for selecting flag-bearers, and those flanking them, in primary school parades. Two pupils in sixth grade (the final year of primary school) will be chosen by lot each year, with one serving from the start of the academic year until January 31 and the other from February 1 to the end of the school year.

This means different pupils will carry the flag in parades to mark Independence Day on March 25 and Oxi Day on October 28, which commemorates Greece’s response to an Italian ultimatum in 1940 and the country’s entry into World War II.

The pupils will be selected by lot, with all class members being eligible. Until now, pupils with the highest marks in their class were selected. After 1990, when many immigrants came to Greece, there were loud debates when the top pupils were children of immigrants, with the public being split between those who saw these flag bearers as validation of a culture of tolerance and others who wanted only Greeks to carry the flag.

New Democracy’s spokesperson for education, Niki Kerameos, accused the government of “overturning a decades-long tradition,” and added, “The message that we give our youth is that they don’t need to make an effort to achieve success, they need only luck.” The Potami party declared that “each day, the SYRIZA-Independent Greeks government shows in word and deed its ideological allergy to all forms of achievement and excellence.”

Shortly after the coalition was formed in early 2015, its first education minister, Aristides Baltas, told Parliament that “excellence is a stain.” On Wednesday, Education Minister Costas Gavroglou declared that every pupil “should have the opportunity to honor the flag and to be honored by it.”

5 Responses

  1. I’d post a ‘like’ if this was on Facebook. Constantly rewarding those who have already achieved just re-inforces false superiority by the few.

    On the other hand, all this nationalistic flag-waving makes me queasy. So I’d post a ‘dislike’ for the whole thing!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. New Democracy’s spokesperson for education [said:] “The message that we give our youth is that they don’t need to make an effort to achieve success, they need only luck.”

    Nothing says old fashioned elitism like “New Democracy”.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. The New Democracy statement (and Yoram’s reaction) shows that the Invisible Hand and Blind Break schools of sortition have nothing in common. It’s also the case that many on the left confuse “old fashioned elitism” with privilege. When my friend Trenton Oldfield jumped into the Thames as a protest against the “elitism” of the Varsity Boat Race (and nearly had his head chopped off by a rowing blade) he should have said he was objecting to privilege (Oxford Brookes [aka Oxford Polytechnic] rowing squad is much better than the University of Oxford).


  4. […] It was reported in August that a lottery is going to be used in Greece to distribute the distinction of carrying the flag. This decision is now being taken to court: […]


  5. […] distribution-by-lot received fairly intense attention in Greece in the context of a debate over the mechanism of selection of flag bearers in […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: